| The History Channel Ultimate Collections: World War II | 
 enlarge | Director: Don Horan
Studio: A&E Home Video
Category: DVD
List Price: $59.95
Buy New: $33.49
You Save: $26.46 (44%)
New (4) Used (5) from $27.39
Avg. Customer Rating:  7 reviews
Sales Rank: 6317
Format: Box Set, Black & White, Color, Dvd-video, Ntsc
Language: English (Original Language)
Rating: NR (Not Rated)
Number Of Items: 10
Running Time: 892
Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1
Shipping Weight (lbs): 1
Dimensions (in): 7.7 x 6.1 x 5.5
MPN: AAED76280D
UPC: 733961762808
EAN: 0733961762808
ASIN: B000H5U5US
Release Date: November 28, 2006
Shipping: Eligible for Super Saver Shipping
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
|
| Similar Items:
|
| Editorial Reviews:
Product Description
Studio: A&e Home Video Release Date: 11/28/2006
|
| Customer Reviews: Read 2 more reviews...
 A brief comment November 30, 2008
2 out of 2 found this review helpful
I note that there are a lot of lukewarm reviews of this set, and even a fair number of negative comments relating to its shortcomings. For me, though, as a beginner in World War II history, something I knew very little about, I found this set quite enjoyable and informative. I liked how each episode is divided into various segments discussing the country's leaders and generals, the armies and positions involved, order of battle, military strategy, and the weapons themselves--ships, tanks, planes, etc. This approach made it very easy for a non-specialist to follow and to learn from.
The footage is truly spectacular; in one film sequence, a Stuka dive-bomber scores a near miss on a tank, which flies up into the air, flips over, and lands on its turret, upside down. Wow. The extensive footage of fighters strafing tanks on the ground, shooting down enemy planes, bombers dropping hundreds of bombs, and battleships firing massive broadsides are amazing to watch. With extensive footage of aerial dogfights, sea battles, artillery, tank, and infantry action, you get fantastic footage of every aspect of mechanized warfare in the 20th century.
Besides the many important facts about the history, you pick up many fascinating smaller tidbits of information. I had thought that the Russian equipment was inferior to the other armies, but the Russian T-34 tank was the best of any tank in WWII. It had thick, sloping armor that the Germans couldn't penetrate initially, since most German tanks were equipped with a lighter machine gun and the heavier, more effective gun was only in limited use by the time of the battle of Russia. During the battle of Stalingrad, the rifles of the Germans froze and often became unusable. But the Russians mixed gasoline with the gun grease, which lowered the freezing point so they still worked. As many German soldiers succumbed to the cold and frostbite as from their wounds, but the Russian soldiers wore layered, quilted tunics that came from the Asian and Mongolian steppes that were warmer, compared to the Germans who just wore the standard woolen winter coats.
I didn't realize flame thrower tanks were in such wide use during WWII, but you often see footage of them in these movies. They were especially effective during the Pacific war when the Japanese would hide in caves behind thick foliage. I once read that being a flame thrower tank soldier was one of the most dangerous assignments, because the tanks were so hated that the crews were often executed on the spot if a flame thrower tank was captured.
Amidst the many horrors of war, there is the occasional scene of humanity. In one scene, a G.I. helps a captured, starving German soldier down from a tank. Back then, we really were still the good guys.
One difference I noted between this series and the Last Days of WWII set, which I'm watching now, is that in the latter production there are numerous interviews with soldiers, on both sides of the war, who participated in these battles. This is a nice feature, although the live interviews don't always shed that much light on the events since many of them are fairly short. But as there will soon be a time when no more surviving WWII veterans exist, again, it's a nice feature to have.
I note that many people seem to prefer the much praised World at War series from the 80s, and the BBC World War II production. Having seen this set now, I intend to get those also now that my interest has been piqued. My only criticism is I agree that at just under 900 minutes, the whole set could have fit on 4 DVDs rather than on 10. Why this was done I don't know, but I do agree with the complaint about this. Overall though, a fine beginner's set that's easy to watch and learn from.
WWII DVD set February 20, 2008
0 out of 3 found this review helpful
I purchased this set for one of my grandchildren and liked it so much that I bought another one for another grandchild.
 Hoping for Something Better May 30, 2007
9 out of 12 found this review helpful
I agree with the majority, that this set is very incomplete. While content presented on WW II is good, I have other issues.
The running time is approximately 810 minutes (not 892 minutes) on 10 DVDs in the standard cases, which requires at least 6 inches of shelf space. Only 4 DVDs were required, but 10 DVDs were used.
I mainly purchased this set for the 10 Military (Great) Blunders episodes. I was hugely disappointed that all episodes ran between 20:55 and 21:07 minutes. I have some of these episodes on VHS and they ran 22 minutes and I was hoping that original running times of perhaps 23 minutes, would be in this set. The problem is the History Channel (and the rest of the TV universe) keeps cutting runing times for more commercials. So, the original episodes no longer exists and you get heavily edited programs. Maybe, if the History Channel had shipped the original, uncut episodes, 892 minutes may have been correct.
Bottomline, while there are much better choices for WW II content, there is some unique information, so that you don't feel too ripped off. But, Cable Networks (e.g. History Channel) are the worst of the worst, with commercials galore and distracting on-screen logos. That's why we buy these DVDs, right?
 Dreadful April 8, 2007
37 out of 43 found this review helpful
I was pleased to see a new "supersized" history of WWII box set come to DVD, and being a superfan of this subject bought it. I wasn't expecting a lot of new footage but I thought perhaps a new perspective would be refreshing.
I'm afraid disappointed is an understatement in describing how I felt while watching it... "War Chronicles" (Mort Zimmerman) was never my favorite of the WWII documentaries, and this box set is built entirely on these old reels.
Patrick O'Neal's voice drones on like the engines of a tired old bomber on a long run to the heart of Germany. You hear little else but his narration over the canned sound effects through the entire series.
I was particularly amazed at the lack of footage devoted to England and the Battle of Britain. Literally a couple of minutes!
A far better choice would be the "BBC History of World War II", The "Definitive History of WWII" (Brentwood), "Visions of War" (Southern Star/IMAVision), or "The World at War" box sets.
If you still wish to have this box set, there will be plenty of very slightly used copies available very cheap, very soon!
 Incomplete documentary of the War April 1, 2007
11 out of 15 found this review helpful
Lacks adequate description of the Eastern Front. Biographies are superfluous and should have been eliminated for " the last days of WWII" History Channel documentary
|
|
|
